Review: The Wicker Man (1973)

The Wicker Man


Robin Hardy
Anthony Shaffer
88 min.
Edward Woodward, Christopher Lee, Diane Cilento, Britt Ekland, Ingrid Pitt, Lindsay Kemp, Russell Waters, Aubrey Morris, Irene Sunter
MPAA Rating

Buy on DVD



The slasher model had not quite made its presence known in the realm of modern horror films. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre was still a year away and Halloween was five off. So, horror was still on a religious kick, scaring people with the prospects of Satanic possession. The first major feature of this type was Roman Polanski’s Rosemary’s Baby leading the charge in 1968. It would be followed five years later by Best Picture nominee The Exorcist and three years further with The Omen.

Yet the idea of pagan religions wasn’t as frequently used, but would get its own shot at the horror audience in 1973 with The Wicker Man, a cult classic (pardoning the pun) about a police officer who finds himself pursuing a missing girl on an island of ritual and mystery where he suspects murder, but finds something more diabolical. Edward Woodward takes on the mantle of the Catholic cop Sergeant Howie who find himself caught in a desperate and dangerous situation. When he arrives there and is told that no one has heard of this girl, he begins uncovering lies, fertility rituals and a childrens’ education system devoted to teaching kids early about the necessity of sex and its impact on culture and nature. Despite being a rather forward decade for psycho-sexual and violent cinematic experiences, Wicker Man is still a bit too advanced for a society still locked in repressed religious belief. It’s why films like Rosemary’s Baby and The Exorcist, apart from being excellent films, managed to touch so evocatively the minds of millions of audiences. They weren’t exactly prepared for what The Wicker Man would have to offer and may have been more offended than entertained.

The film isn’t about its performances, which are notably lacking. It isn’t about its scares and thrills, there aren’t any. It’s about the shock factor. It’s about dealing both seriously and not-so-seriously about the lack of religious tolerance in society and doing so almost surreptitiously. Although this island community has its share of unusual and aberrant customs, it’s the words of their Lord Summerisle, played acerbically by horror legend Christopher Lee, that seem to linger. In one scene where Sergeant Howie is questioning the fakeness of their religious pursuits, questioning the wisdom of the unusual concept of reproduction without sexual union, and asking him if the children have never learned of Jesus, he wittily responds “himself the son of a virgin, impregnated, I believe, by a ghost…”

Yet, for all its forward thinking, The Wicker Man still focuses the audience squarely against the pagan cult and vilifies it in the final scenes as the crowd sings and raises praise to their gods as the wicker man himself burns away the offerings they have provided. However, I must give it credit for at least trying to go a different way with its concept, I just wish it hadn’t been so effectively against religious tolerance.
Review Written
September 6, 2010


Add a Comment
  1. “ALL gods ultimately fail their devotees” is reading much to deeply into the movie. Just because someone who has faith is not saved from a fiery death or accident does not mean the gods have failed. I personally believe in religion because life and this world are just too miraculous.
    Oh the movie was more about a particular people’s strange paganish religion and the horrific situation that ensued. It was an excellent build up, a strange and exhilirating vibe and then some real freakiness.

  2. ‘The film isn’t about its performances, which are notably lacking. It isn’t about its scares and thrills, there aren’t any.’

    Are you kidding?! The performances are absolutely fantastic, Edward Woodward’s in particular. And what can be more chilling than human sacrifice being practiced in contemporary society? I don’t think you do this film justice.

  3. Babette de Meyrignac

    Surely the whole point of the Wicker Man is that ALL gods ultimately fail their devotees? Summerisle’s gods allowed the vital harvest to fail- Howies’s Jesus failed to save him from a terrible death. Religion? Just say No!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.