Below is the list of films I’ve seen and haven’t along with the number of nominations and wins each title received. I’ll follow these up with my reviews (a link to the original review if possible) of each title on the list. I’ve also included a gallery of posters for the films that were nominated in 1928/29 if I can find them.

My goal will be to eventually catch all winners (if available), then focus on nominees.

Seen [3 nominations, 1 wins]:

The Broadway Melody [3, 1]

Not Seen [26 nominations, 5 wins]:

Alibi [3, 0]
Coquette [1, 1]
The Divine Lady [3, 1] (Warner Archive)
Hollywood Revue [1, 0] (Warner Archive)
In Old Arizona [5, 1]
The Letter [1, 0] (Warner Archive)
Madame X [2, 0] (Warner Archive)
Our Dancing Daughters [2, 0] (Warner Archive)
Street Angel [2, 0]
Weary River [1, 0] (Warner Archive)
White Shadows in the South Seas [1, 1] (Warner Archive)

Incomplete or Hard to Find Films [10 nominations, 0 wins]:

The Barker [1, 0] (UCLA has a print)
The Bridge of San Luis Rey [2, 1] (George Eastman House)
The Cop [1, 0] (Library of Congress has a print)
Dynamite [1, 0] (shown on TCM)
The Last of Mrs. Cheyney [1, 0] (bootleg copies only)
The Leatherneck [1, 0] (TV print still exists)
Sal of Singapore [1, 0] (UCLA has a print)
Skyscraper [1, 0] (UCLA has a print)
Thunderbolt [1, 0] (bootleg copies only)
The Valiant [2, 0] (bootleg copies only)
A Woman of Affairs [1, 0] (bootleg copies only)

Lost Films [8 nominations, 1 win]:

The Awakening [1, 0]
Drag [1, 0]
Four Devils [1, 0]
The Patriot [5, 1]
Wonder of Women [1, 0]

Reviews:

The Broadway Melody (2 stars)
My Full Review

Purchase Available Films

Gallery of Posters